Are Fixed Annuities Paying More Than US Treasuries?

Are you seeking a stable income stream for your retirement years? With interest rates at an all-time high, are fixed annuities paying more than US Treasuries?

In this article, we will delve into the world of fixed annuities and US Treasuries, comparing their features, benefits, and potential drawbacks to help you make an informed decision for your retirement planning needs.


  • Fixed annuities and US Treasuries are popular options for retirement planning.
  • MYGAs offer higher interest rates than US Treasuries, and at the same time fixed annuities provide tax benefits such as tax-deferred growth.
  • It is important to evaluate risk tolerance and investment goals when deciding between these two products in order to create a tailored plan that meets individual needs.

Need help choosing the best annuity for your unique situation? If so, it’s best to speak with an annuity specialist. Watch this short video to see how I can help you do this (at no cost to you!).

Comparing Fixed Annuities and US Treasuries

Fixed annuities and US Treasuries are two popular investment options for retirement planning, each offering distinct advantages and features.

Fixed annuities are contracts with insurance companies guaranteeing an income stream for a set period or for life, while US Treasuries are government-issued debt securities with varying maturities and fixed interest rates, deemed low-risk investments.

The current interest rate environment has pushed Treasury yields above 5%, presenting a lucrative opportunity for fixed annuity sales, including deferred income annuities. Historically, higher rates have been associated with higher fixed annuity sales.

We’ll explore each investment option in detail to comprehend their advantages and disadvantages more effectively.

What are US Treasuries?

US Treasuries are government-issued debt securities that come with varying maturity periods and a fixed interest rate, making them low-risk investments.

Since the establishment of the United States Treasury Department in 1789, the government has been issuing securities such as Treasury bonds, notes, and bills to manage revenue.

Available US Treasuries include:

  • Treasury bills
  • Treasury notes
  • Treasury bonds
  • Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS)

Treasury Notes have maturities of 2, 3, 5, 7, or 10 years, while Treasury Bonds have maturities of 20 or 30 years.

What are Fixed Annuities?

Fixed annuities are contracts with insurance companies that offer a guaranteed income stream for a predetermined period or for life.

They provide tax-deferred growth and potential death benefits. Immediate annuities, a type of fixed annuity, begin paying out immediately after the investment is made with an insurance company.

Available fixed annuity types include fixed rate deferred annuities, which allow investors to determine when payments begin, and Multi-Year Guarantee Annuities (MYGAs), which provide a guaranteed rate of interest for a period of two to 10 years without a sales charge.

Fixed annuities offer several benefits, such as providing a guaranteed income for life and tax-deferred growth during the accumulation phase, but also come with drawbacks, including a lack of liquidity and potential surrender fees.

In contrast to variable annuities, fixed annuities provide more stability and predictability for investors.

Current Interest Rates: A Key Factor

In the current high-interest rate climate, fixed annuities have become an appealing investment option, with MYGAs providing competitive rates relative to US Treasuries. Annuity payouts from fixed annuities can provide a stable income stream during retirement.

It should be mentioned that while fixed annuity rates don’t have a direct correlation with US Treasury rates, they often mirror trends in bond interest rates, including those of US Treasuries. 

The current high-interest rate climate makes fixed annuities, especially MYGAs with their competitive rates, a worthy consideration for your retirement planning strategy. With Treasury yields currently between 4 and 5%, it’s worth exploring the potential for higher returns with fixed annuities.

Click here to learn how to find the best annuity rates for you

MYGAs vs. Treasury Bonds: A Rate Comparison

When comparing MYGA rates and Treasury bond yields, it’s evident that MYGA rates are typically higher. With the highest MYGA rates ranging from 4.05% for one year to 6% for seven and ten years, they offer an attractive alternative to Treasury securities and certificates of deposit.

The rate of return for MYGAs and Treasury bonds is primarily determined by prevailing interest rates in the market. MYGA rates can be more sensitive to changes in the economy compared to Treasury bonds, responding to interest rate fluctuations accordingly.

In the current interest rate environment, MYGAs offer a potential advantage in terms of higher returns compared to US Treasuries. This makes them an attractive option for investors seeking to maximize their retirement income.

Tax Benefits of Fixed Annuities

Fixed annuities offer a significant advantage over US Treasuries in terms of tax benefits. They enable investors to accrue wealth through tax-deferred growth, meaning taxes on returns are not incurred until withdrawal.

In contrast, interest earned from US Treasuries is subject to federal income taxes, but exempt from state and local taxes.

This tax-deferred growth benefit of fixed annuities, including the deferred income annuity, can help investors accumulate more wealth over time on a tax deferred basis, making them a more attractive choice for retirement planning, especially when compared to interest payments on other investments.

Diversifying Your Retirement Portfolio

Diversifying your retirement portfolio is vital for balancing risk and maximizing potential returns. A mix of fixed annuities, index annuities, and US Treasuries can provide exposure to different prospects and trends across asset classes, lessen risk, and potentially augment the risk-adjusted rate of return.

Fixed annuities offer a guaranteed rate of return and may generate a stable fixed income stream during retirement. Index annuities, on the other hand, offer the potential for higher returns based on the performance of a specific index while providing a degree of protection against losses. Index annuities may also provide a guaranteed stream of income in retirement with the selection of an income rider.

US Treasuries are considered low-risk investments and can provide a reliable source of income, but it is worth considering that that income can fluctuate over the years.

Incorporating different types of investments into your retirement portfolio can help diversify risk and potentially enhance overall returns. This balanced approach can safeguard your retirement income and ensure you’re prepared for any market fluctuations.

Consult a Trusted Advisor

Consulting a professional can provide you with the information necessary to make an informed decision about which investment option best suits your retirement planning objectives: fixed annuities or US Treasuries.

An advisor can help you evaluate your risk tolerance, investment goals, and time horizon to tailor a retirement plan that meets your needs.

They can help you with your retirement planning by:

  • Understanding your risk tolerance and investment goals
  • Suggesting suitable investment opportunities that align with your financial objectives and time horizon
  • Ensuring you make the right investment decisions for your future

Don’t leave your retirement planning to chance; consult an annuity expert to ensure you make the right investment decisions for your future.


In conclusion, fixed annuities and US Treasuries offer distinct benefits and features that can play a crucial role in your retirement planning strategy. Fixed annuities, with their tax-deferred growth and guaranteed income streams, may be an attractive option in the current high-interest rate environment.

Remember to evaluate your risk tolerance, investment goals, and time horizon when deciding between fixed annuities and US Treasuries.

Diversifying your retirement portfolio with a mix of these investments can help balance risk and provide guaranteed income streams.

By consulting with an annuity expert, you can make educated decisions regarding your annuity investments, ensuring a safe and secure retirement income strategy that meets your unique financial goals and needs.

Click here to schedule a call.

Scroll to Top