Why Average Investment Returns Can Mislead Retirees

Average investment returns can mislead retirees because the market does not deliver steady growth every year. When you start taking withdrawals, a few bad years early in retirement can change how long your money lasts.

I often hear people build their retirement plans around an assumed return of 8% or 10%. Those assumptions may look reassuring on paper, but they do not tell you what happens if the market drops right when you need income.

I want to show you why those averages can fall short and how I approach separating retirement income from money invested for growth.

Need help choosing the best annuity for your unique situation? Have questions about getting an annuity? If so, it’s best to speak with an annuity specialist. Watch this short video to see how I can help you do this (at no cost to you!)

Tip: See how much an annuity could pay you using my annuity calculator

Book a Call with Me

If you want to chat about purchasing an annuity and want unbiased advice and access to all top annuities, then I would encourage you to book a call with me!

Why Average Investment Returns Do Not Tell the Whole Story

You have probably heard someone say you can plan around a 10% return because of the stock market’s long-term performance. The problem is treating a historical average as though it were a predictable annual paycheck.

Think about the dot-com bust and the housing crash. Those downturns created difficult stretches for investors, particularly people who needed to withdraw money while their investments were down.

A retirement calculator might show a smooth upward curve. Your actual retirement will include good years, bad years, and expenses that continue regardless of market performance.

An average return does not tell you when losses will happen, how long recovery will take, or how withdrawals will affect your balance.

What Happens When a Market Crash Comes First?

In the video above, I start with a simple illustration: $1 million growing at an assumed 10% annually for 25 years, with no additional contributions or withdrawals. Under those assumptions, the ending balance exceeds $10 million.

That looks great. But what happens if the first three years bring a substantial downturn and your balance falls 40%?

Now you have $600,000, with 22 years remaining in that original timeframe. If that smaller balance grows at 10% annually for those remaining years, it reaches approximately $4.88 million.

These scenarios do not have the same return over the entire 25 years. The second scenario includes an early loss followed by an assumed 10% annual return, which shows how dramatically a downturn can change a smooth-growth projection.

The retirement problem gets more serious when you also take withdrawals. You are removing money from a smaller account, leaving less invested to participate in a recovery.

That is where sequence of returns risk becomes especially important: the order of investment gains and losses can affect how long a portfolio lasts when you are withdrawing income.

💡 Pro Tip: Ask to see a retirement projection with substantial losses in the first few years, including your planned withdrawals. A smooth average-return projection alone does not show that risk.

Does a 3% Withdrawal Rate Solve the Problem?

You might respond by taking less from your investments. Instead of starting with a 4% withdrawal, perhaps you start with 3%.

On a $1 million portfolio, that means $30,000 in first-year income. The first question I would ask is whether that provides the retirement lifestyle you actually want.

The next question is what happens as your expenses rise. If you increase withdrawals to account for inflation, you are asking the portfolio to support a larger dollar withdrawal over time.

In the illustration I discuss in the video above, the money lasts into later retirement but eventually runs out. That is an outcome under those particular assumptions, not a prediction that every portfolio using a 3% withdrawal rate will fail.

A lower starting withdrawal can reduce pressure on your savings, but it does not guarantee lifetime income. Your results still depend on returns, inflation, spending, and how long you live.

How Can an Annuity Separate Income From Market Growth?

One approach I use is to give different portions of retirement savings different jobs. Part provides contractual lifetime income, while another part remains invested for growth.

In the video above, I illustrate a couple who are both 65 and have $1 million. They allocate:

  • $600,000 to an annuity with a lifetime income rider.
  • $400,000 to investments that remain exposed to the market.

The annuity illustrations shown in the video offered approximately $44,000 a year in joint lifetime income from that $600,000 allocation. Those were example quotes, not a promise of the same payout for every couple or a current offer.

This is why I like looking at annuities as a way to create pension-like income. You assign part of your money to an income obligation so your entire retirement paycheck does not depend on selling investments.

The income guarantee depends on the issuing insurer’s claims-paying ability and following the contract’s terms. The remaining investments can still rise or fall.

👉 Want to compare income options for your situation? Visit my website to use the calculators or schedule a call with me.

What happens if the annuity account balance runs out?

In the example, I use an indexed annuity with an income rider. Withdrawals and rider fees reduce the account value, while credited interest may add to it.

Eventually, that account value can reach zero. The account-value death benefit can also be depleted.

However, qualifying lifetime income payments can continue under the rider’s terms even after the account value is exhausted. The account balance and the lifetime income guarantee are different things.

I want you to understand that distinction before purchasing. This example focuses on lifetime income, and it does not promise that your original premium will remain available to your heirs.

What About Inflation, Market Losses, and Delaying Income?

The $400,000 left invested has a separate purpose. It gives you money with growth potential that you may later use for additional income or other needs.

If the portfolio performs well, you might use a portion every five to seven years to purchase more income. That is one possible way to help address rising expenses, but it depends on investment performance and future annuity options.

The initial fixed income payment does not automatically increase with inflation. Buying additional income requires additional money.

What if the remaining investments fall by half?

Suppose that $400,000 falls to $200,000 during a severe downturn. That would be disappointing, but the annuity income in this illustration would continue according to the contract, alongside your Social Security benefits.

You might postpone purchasing additional income and give the investments more time to recover. Recovery and future growth are not guaranteed, so this part of the plan needs flexibility.

The benefit is that you are less dependent on selling those investments to cover the income already provided by the annuity.

Can waiting to start annuity income increase the payment?

It can. In the video’s illustrations, allocating $600,000 at age 65 and waiting until age 67 produced quoted income of approximately $55,000 annually for one option.

Another illustrated contract offered roughly $44,000 for an immediate start, $48,000 after waiting one year, and $53,000 after waiting two years. These figures were specific to the illustrated products and assumptions.

A higher future payment also means waiting to receive income. I would compare both the payment amount and the income you forgo during that waiting period.

💡 Pro Tip: Compare annuity illustrations using the same ages, premium, income start date, and joint-life coverage. Otherwise, the payout numbers may not be directly comparable.

Conclusion

I do not want your retirement confidence to depend entirely on an assumed average return. I want you to understand what happens if the market has a difficult stretch, your expenses increase, or you live longer than expected.

An annuity is one tool for addressing those concerns. For some retirees, using part of their assets for contractual income can make it easier to leave the remaining investments alone during market downturns.

I sell annuities and earn commissions when clients purchase them through me. My goal is to help you compare the available options, review the fees and limitations, and find a contract that fits your needs.

I can provide brochures, walk through illustrations, and answer your questions so you understand what you are buying.

Need help with finding the best annuity for your retirement?

Click here to schedule a call with me.

On the call, I can help you:

  • Determine what type of annuity is best for you
  • Find the highest paying annuities for your unique situation
  • Answer any other questions you may have

Frequently Asked Questions

Scroll to Top