When people compare fixed indexed annuities, they often focus on products from A-rated insurance companies. But what about the best annuity cap and participation rates available from B++ carriers?
B++ carriers can offer competitive growth opportunities, strong market protection, and sometimes better cap or participation rates. However, the highest advertised rate is not always the most important number.
You also need to consider fees, premium bonuses, index history, and whether the carrier has a reputation for maintaining its rates after the first contract year.
Need help choosing the best annuity for your unique situation? Have questions about getting an annuity? If so, it’s best to speak with an annuity specialist. Watch this short video to see how I can help you do this (at no cost to you!)
Tip: See how much an annuity could pay you using my annuity calculator
What Does a B++ Insurance Rating Mean?
A B++ rating does not automatically mean an insurance company is bad or unsafe. It generally means the company has less capital or fewer reserves than an A-, A, or A+ rated carrier.
Because of that, a B++ carrier may be viewed as carrying slightly more financial risk. However, many B++ carriers have been operating successfully for decades and can still provide substantial contractual protections.
I work with several B++ companies that provide excellent products and customer service. Some of these carriers are actively growing, which can make them more competitive when attracting new business.
A carrier’s financial rating should still be considered, but it should not be the only factor used when choosing an annuity.
💡 Pro Tip: Compare the carrier’s financial strength, product terms, renewal-rate history, surrender period, and income guarantees (not just the initial cap or participation rate).
Nassau’s Annuity Cap and Participation Rates
Nassau is one of the more established B++ carriers I work with. It offers several index choices, including familiar options connected to the S&P 500 and NASDAQ.
In the illustration reviewed for this comparison, Nassau offered examples including:
- A 66% enhanced S&P 500 participation rate with an account fee
- A 47% NASDAQ participation rate
- An S&P 500 cap of approximately 10%
- A fixed account rate of approximately 4.5%
These rates can change based on the product, state, premium amount, surrender period, and current cost of the underlying options.
The longer you agree to leave your money in an annuity, the more competitive the carrier may be able to make its rates. A 10-year product, for example, may provide a higher cap or participation rate than a five-year product.
However, you should never choose an annuity based only on the highest first-year rate.
👉 Want help comparing current annuity cap and participation rates? Schedule a call with me.
Is a Cap or Participation Rate Better?
A cap places a maximum on the interest you can receive during a crediting period.
For example, suppose your annuity has a 10% cap and the index increases by 12%. Your credited interest would generally be limited to 10%.
A participation rate determines what percentage of the index gain is used to calculate your interest.
For example, with a 50% participation rate:
- If the index rises 10%, you could receive 5%
- If the index rises 20%, you could receive 10%
- If the index rises 30%, you could receive 15%
Participation rates can perform well during unusually strong market years because there may not be a traditional cap limiting the final credited amount.
Caps can sometimes be more attractive during average market years. If the market earns 12% and your cap is 10%, you may receive the full 10%. With a 50% participation rate, you would receive only 6%.
Since nobody knows what the market will do next, it may make sense to divide the allocation between multiple crediting strategies instead of placing everything into one option.
EquiTrust and Renewal-Rate Integrity
EquiTrust is another B++ carrier I regularly work with. One of the main reasons I like EquiTrust is its history of maintaining relatively consistent renewal rates.
Cap and participation rates are generally guaranteed only for the stated crediting period. With a one-year point-to-point strategy, the rate normally applies for that year. The carrier can then adjust it for the following year.
That makes renewal-rate integrity extremely important.
A product may offer a very high cap, participation rate, and premium bonus during the first year. But if the carrier reduces those rates substantially at renewal, the contract may only average 2% or 3% afterward.
In the comparison discussed, EquiTrust offered examples including:
- A 70% S&P 500 participation rate with a 1% account fee
- A 50% S&P 500 participation rate without an account fee
- Cap and monthly-sum strategies without an account fee
- A fixed account rate of approximately 5.25%
I have also seen EquiTrust clients receive strong credited interest during favorable index years. However, I would never build a retirement recommendation around an assumption that someone will consistently earn 12%, 14%, or more.
I would rather illustrate a conservative and realistic return so that the client is still satisfied many years later.
Should You Pay an Account Fee for a Higher Rate?
Some indexed annuity strategies charge an annual fee in exchange for a higher participation rate.
For example, a no-fee option might provide a 50% participation rate, while a strategy charging a 1% fee might provide a 70% participation rate.
The higher rate can produce more credited interest during a strong market year. However, the fee can still be deducted during a year when the index declines.
You are generally protected from direct market losses, but you could still see the account value reduced by the strategy fee or rider charge.
That does not make fee-based strategies bad. It simply means the potential benefit must justify the added cost.
For someone who does not want an account fee, I may consider spreading the allocation among options such as:
- A one-year S&P 500 cap
- An S&P 500 monthly-sum cap
- A monthly-average participation-rate strategy
- A fixed-interest allocation
This creates a more balanced approach without relying entirely on one index calculation.
Premium Bonuses Are Not Free Money
A large premium bonus can look extremely attractive. If you deposit $100,000 into an annuity offering a 21% bonus, the contract may immediately show an additional $21,000.
That bonus is real, but it normally comes with tradeoffs.
The carrier may offer lower future caps or participation rates because a large portion of the contract’s value was provided upfront. The contract may also have a longer surrender period or bonus recapture provisions.
Premium bonuses can still be useful, particularly when someone is replacing an existing annuity with surrender charges. A bonus may help offset some or all of those charges.
But when surrender charges are not an issue, I usually place more importance on long-term renewal rates than on receiving the largest possible upfront bonus.
You should also be careful with indexes that have very little live history. A hypothetical backtest can look impressive, but it does not show how that index will perform in real-world conditions.
I generally prefer recognizable indexes with longer histories, such as the traditional S&P 500, rather than relying heavily on a newly created strategy.
Conclusion
B++ carriers such as Nassau and EquiTrust can offer competitive annuity cap and participation rates. They may be appropriate for someone who wants index-linked growth potential while remaining protected from direct market losses.
However, the best annuity is not necessarily the one with the highest advertised first-year rate. You need to evaluate the carrier’s financial rating, renewal-rate history, fees, index options, surrender terms, and contractual guarantees.
The right choice also depends on your primary goal. An annuity designed for accumulation may not provide the highest lifetime income. If your priority is contractual retirement income, an income rider, SPIA, or DIA may need to be compared separately.
Need help with finding the best annuity for your retirement?
Click here to schedule a call with me.
On the call, I can help you:
- Determine what type of annuity is best for you
- Find the highest paying annuities for your unique situation
- Answer any other questions you may have