What You Need to Know Before Making a 1035 Exchange for Annuities

Thinking about making a 1035 exchange for annuities? To make a choice that’s both sound and tax-smart, familiarize yourself with what you need to know before making a 1035 exchange for annuities.

From the tax benefits to the considerations that might affect your finances, we offer insights into the essential elements that will impact the success of your exchange. Steer clear of the common traps and tailor your decision to your personal financial situation with the guidance laid out in this article.


  • A 1035 exchange allows for the tax-free transfer of funds from one annuity to another without changing ownership, aiming to leverage tax deferral benefits and other tax advantages.
  • These exchanges must be reported on annual tax returns despite being non-taxable events; careful consideration of partial exchanges and outstanding loans is necessary due to their specific tax implications.
  • Before proceeding with a 1035 exchange, it’s critical to assess the insurance company’s financial strength and compatibility with financial goals, understanding of policy features and costs, and financial strength.

Need help choosing the best annuity for your unique situation? Have questions about getting an annuity? If so, it’s best to speak with an annuity specialist. Watch this short video to see how I can help you do this (at no cost to you!).

Understanding 1035 Exchanges for Annuities

To comprehend the notion of 1035 exchanges for annuities, you must first understand their essence and significance.

Section 1035 of the tax code, also known as the Internal Revenue Code, governs 1035 exchanges, which enable the tax-free transfer of certain insurance products, like life insurance, annuities, and endowments, to similar products.

This provides individuals with a valuable option for managing their insurance assets. This means you can transfer funds from one annuity to another, provided you remain the policyholder and no change in ownership or insured individuals occurs.

One might wonder why someone would opt for this – the reasoning is embedded in the very purpose of a 1035 exchange. It’s a strategic move aimed at leveraging tax deferral benefits and, in situations where the original contract has no gain, it can still offer other tax advantages over surrendering the contract.

Understanding the dynamics of a 1035 exchange is pivotal as it significantly impacts financial planning. Owners must be fully informed about the transaction to ensure it aligns with their economic or personal factors.

Definition of a 1035 Exchange

Let’s further explore the intricate realm of 1035 exchanges. A 1035 exchange, also known as a like-kind exchange, is a legal way to swap one insurance policy, annuity, or endowment for a similar product without triggering tax on any investment gains associated with the original contract.

Think of it as a tax-free makeover for your investment portfolio.

Under the IRS code, it is possible to transfer an existing annuity contract, life insurance policy, long-term care product, or endowment for another one of like kind in a 1035 exchange, and this transfer is tax-free.

But remember, these exchanges are tax deferments, not tax deductions or credits. They are particularly beneficial for policyholders seeking to upgrade their insurance coverage or adjust their investment strategy within annuities, ensuring that the transaction remains non-taxable.

Purpose of a 1035 Exchange

Having defined the concept of a 1035 exchange, it’s time to understand their inherent advantages.

The purpose of a 1035 exchange is to change life insurance policies or annuity choices without triggering taxes, which can be advantageous when needing more coverage or seeking contracts with better terms or lower fees.

So, if your current life insurance or annuity no longer fits your needs, a 1035 exchange allows for an upgrade or change in investment strategy without incurring tax consequences.

The main benefits of a 1035 exchange include:

  • The ability to trade for products with better terms, like lower fees, better investment options, or less restrictive provisions
  • The ability to exchange a variable annuity for a fixed or a fixed index annuity
  • The possibility of receiving a premium or bonus with new annuity contracts through a 1035 exchange
  • Access to new features that may be available with the new contract
  • The potential for lower costs with the new contract
  • Improved death and life benefits

These benefits make a 1035 exchange a valuable option for annuity holders.

Tax Implications of a 1035 Exchange

One of the pivotal elements of a 1035 exchange encompasses its tax implications. The good news is that no tax is due on the gain in the original policy when transferring into the new policy, and the gains continue to be tax-deferred in the new annuity.

This means you can switch to a new policy that better suits your needs without worrying about immediate tax liabilities.

However, it’s important to note that a 1035 exchange must be reported on your annual tax return using Form 1099-R, even though the exchange itself isn’t taxable.

Additionally, while partial 1035 exchanges are permitted, it’s crucial to understand the specific tax consequences, such as whether there is a gain on the original contract or if there are outstanding loans representing a partial gain.

Tax-Free Transfers

Now, let’s unravel the specifics of tax-free transfers. A 1035 exchange allows for the tax-free transfer of an existing annuity contract for another one of like kind, with direct transfer of funds between financial institutions required.

This means you don’t have to worry about handling the funds yourself, which could potentially trigger tax consequences.

The tax basis from the original annuity contract is carried over to the new contract during a 1035 exchange, enabling potential tax-free withdrawals, reportable on Form 1099-R but not taxable.

However, there are tax consequences if the annuity contract being exchanged has outstanding loans, and partial exchanges allocate only a portion of the cost basis to the new product.

Therefore, it’s important to:

  • Engage in a 1035 exchange
  • Properly manage subsequent premiums
  • Avoid the contract being classified as a modified endowment contract (MEC)
  • Maintain favorable tax treatment

This allows you to maintain the income tax-free status, which is one of the primary benefits of this financial maneuver.

Maintaining Tax-Deferred Status

One of the notable perks of a 1035 exchange is the opportunity to uphold the tax-deferred status. After the exchange, the earnings from your annuity continue to grow tax-deferred. This simply means you won’t pay taxes on the earnings until you withdraw them, allowing your investment to grow faster.

In a full exchange, the cost basis of the original annuity is carried over to the new annuity, ensuring that the same tax-deferred status is maintained. However, in partial exchanges of an annuity, only a portion of the cost basis is allocated to the new product instead of the entire basis.

Furthermore, if the old annuity contract has a loss, with its adjusted basis greater than its current cash value, a 1035 exchange allows you to carry over the higher basis into the new contract, preserving the tax benefits.

Comparing 1035 Exchanges to Real Estate Exchanges

For a better grasp on 1035 exchanges, it is beneficial to draw parallels with a similar concept. Real estate exchanges, also known as 1031 exchanges, offer a similar benefit of tax deferral or avoidance on the exchange of certain types of assets.

However, while 1035 exchanges focus on insurance and annuities, 1031 exchanges primarily deal with real estate.

Both types of exchanges facilitate the continuation of investments while deferring tax consequences. A 1035 exchange involves the tax-free exchange of insurance products, while a 1031 exchange pertains to the exchange of real estate properties without immediate tax liability.

The 1035 exchange specifically caters to the insurance domain allowing for exchanges between life insurance or annuity policies, as opposed to the 1031 exchange which deals with real estate investments.

Shared Benefits

Despite their disparities, 1035 and 1031 exchanges do share a few mutual benefits. Both provide tax efficiencies when exchanging certain types of insurance and financial products or real estate properties.

The Pension Protection Act of 2006 extended the benefits of 1035 exchanges to include exchanges of non-qualified annuities for long-term care insurance policies.

These exchanges offer tax advantages similar to those found in 1031 exchanges used for real estate. The shared tax benefits underline how both 1035 and 1031 exchanges can be utilized to efficiently manage and transition assets in a tax-advantaged manner.

Differences in Assets

While 1035 and 1031 exchanges do bear certain similarities, there are substantial differences in the assets they cater to. A 1035 exchange is specifically designed for certain insurance and annuity products, including life insurance policies, non-qualified annuities, and long-term care insurance.

On the other hand, a 1031 exchange is applicable to real estate transactions, permitting the deferral of capital gains tax when one investment property is traded for another property of like-kind.

So, while a 1035 exchange involves insurance or annuity policies, a 1031 exchange pertains to swapping investment properties to postpone paying capital gains taxes.

The 1035 Transfer Process

Equipped with the knowledge of what a 1035 exchange is and how it compares and contrasts with a 1031 exchange, let’s navigate through the process of executing a 1035 exchange.

At its core, a 1035 transfer is a process of moving funds from a 401k to an Individual Retirement Account (IRA), or from one IRA to another.

This may sound simple, but it involves several steps and requirements that must be met to ensure a smooth and successful transfer. Let’s take a closer look at these in the following subsections.

Eligibility Requirements

Certain eligibility prerequisites must be satisfied for a valid execution of a 1035 exchange. The annuitant or policyholder must remain the same before and after the exchange. In other words, you can’t change the owner or annuitant of the policy during the exchange.

The contract or policy owner must also meet certain requirements for a 1035 transfer, although rules may vary by company. Therefore, it’s crucial to understand these requirements and ensure you meet them before initiating a 1035 exchange.

Steps for Completing a 1035 Transfer

Having comprehended the eligibility prerequisites, it’s time to walk through the steps involved in a 1035 exchange. First, you must contact your current insurer to understand the specific paperwork requirements needed for the transfer.

Next, you’ll need to fill out and submit a new annuity application, which must include a request form specifically for the 1035 transfer to the new policy.

Upon issuing the new contract, the funds are directly transferred from the old to the new policy, ensuring you do not take constructive receipt of the funds which could result in tax implications.

It’s important to note that in a 1035 exchange, an existing contract can be consolidated with multiple other contracts into one new contract. Still, a single contract cannot be split into multiple new contracts.

Factors to Consider Before Making a 1035 Exchange

Before embarking on a 1035 exchange, it is imperative to assess its potential impact on your financial blueprint. This includes considerations such as:

  • Health considerations
  • Waiting periods
  • Possible premium changes
  • Loans against the policy
  • Improved policy benefits or features

Conducting a cost-benefit analysis is essential to determine if the new annuity product aligns with investment goals and retirement objectives. When considering a new annuity, it’s important to review:

  • Mortality risks
  • Administrative charges
  • Investment fees
  • Potential changes in premium rates due to increased age
  • The health status of the insured

Ensuring that these factors align with financial objectives will help make an informed decision about the new fixed annuity.

Lastly, it’s wise to investigate the financial ratings and statements of the new financial institution to ensure their ability to manage assets and fulfill policy obligations.

Financial Goals

Pondering over a 1035 exchange necessitates the consideration of your financial objectives. Your specific needs, goals, and long-term financial plan should guide your decision-making process. It is important to align your decisions with what is important to you and your financial future..

Consider a 1035 exchange when your current policy isn’t aligned with your goals and when a new policy can offer better benefits at the same or lower cost. It also makes sense if your existing policy is maturing.

It’s essential to carefully evaluate whether the new policy’s benefits align with your investment and retirement goals, considering any benefits that might be forfeited in the exchange.

You may also consider a 1035 exchange to take advantage of tax benefits, even if there is no gain in the original contract. These benefits are not available if the contract is simply surrendered.

Annuity Features and Costs

A crucial factor to weigh in is the features and costs associated with the new annuity. When considering a 1035 exchange, compare the new annuity’s features with those of the existing policy, ensuring that any desirable benefits are not lost.

Review policy provisions and interest crediting methods to determine if the new annuity is compatible with current needs. Evaluate the additional benefits and features offered by the existing annuity versus the new annuity, such as living benefits, to ensure they align with personal needs.

Consider surrender charges and the possibility of a higher rate being applied to the net amount of the new policy after these charges.

Lastly, ensure the new annuity’s investment options align with current investment goals, and factor in the timing of the exchange in relation to market performance.

Insurance Company Ratings

Ratings of insurance companies also hold significant sway in the decision-making process pertaining to a 1035 exchange.

Providing essential insights when contemplating a 1035 exchange for non-qualified annuity products is crucial for making informed decisions.

These ratings serve as indicators of the financial strength and stability of an insurance company.

A lower-rated insurance company may represent a higher risk of default or inability to pay out policyholder claims, which is a crucial consideration in the decision-making process for a 1035 exchange, especially when dealing with the same insurance company.

Potential Drawbacks and Risks of a 1035 Exchange

As with any financial decision, a 1035 exchange carries its own set of potential pitfalls and risks. For example, surrender charges may apply to a 1035 exchange and are not typically waived unless exchanging within the same company.

Engaging in a 1035 exchange can have several potential drawbacks, including:

  • Loss of accrued benefits or guarantees associated with the original annuity contract
  • Financial outcome of the exchange being influenced by market conditions at the time
  • Extra charges or premiums that may be offset by other fees
  • Extended surrender period on the new annuity

It’s important to carefully consider these factors before deciding to proceed with a 1035 exchange.

Surrender Charges

Surrender charges are fees imposed by insurance companies for withdrawing funds from an annuity or canceling it before a specified period. The surrender charge is usually a percentage of the amount withdrawn and decreases annually until it no longer applies.

Surrender charges work as a fee applied when withdrawing funds from an annuity during an initial preset number of years, known as the surrender charge period.

Therefore, it’s essential to examine the surrender periods of both the existing and the new annuity, as a new contract may extend this period, affecting fund accessibility.

Loss of Benefits

Conducting a 1035 exchange could result in the loss of grandfathered benefits, which may have provided valuable financial protection or benefits to the policyholder. Grandfathered benefits are those particular guarantees or riders included in an original annuity contract or a life insurance contract.

Policyholders need to weigh the consequences of losing grandfathered benefits against the advantages of the new annuity contract before proceeding with a 1035 exchange. This is a critical factor to consider as you don’t want to lose valuable benefits in the pursuit of new ones.

Market Conditions

Finally, considering market conditions is a vital element when mulling over a 1035 exchange. A market rate adjustment provision in the existing variable or universal annuity contract can influence the amount received from a 1035 exchange.

Also, you should evaluate the commission structure of the new annuity to ensure it aligns with policyholder needs rather than being influenced by market-driven broker incentives. A thorough understanding of market conditions will help you make a more informed decision.


A 1035 exchange for annuities is a powerful tool in financial planning.

It allows for the tax-free transfer of insurance products to similar products, providing numerous benefits such as tax deferral, the ability to upgrade insurance coverage, and the adjustment of investment strategy without incurring tax consequences.

Booking a call with an annuity expert can provide personalized guidance on annuity strategies and help you make informed decisions about your retirement income.

I can help you:

  • Understand the pros and cons of different annuity withdrawal options
  • Determine the best solution for your unique circumstances
  • Navigate and make crucial decisions during your financial journey
  • Find the best annuities for your unique situation

By clicking here to schedule a call, I can take a look at specific annuity options and strategize on how to minimize surrender charges. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Scroll to Top