If you’re searching for the safest type of annuity in today’s market, you’re usually asking one simple question:
“How do I protect my principal and still get a fair return or reliable income?”
In most cases, the safest annuities are fixed annuities (MYGAs) and fixed index annuities (FIAs)—not variable annuities. Below is a clear, practical breakdown so you can match the right annuity to the right goal.
Need help choosing the best annuity for your unique situation? Have questions about getting an annuity? If so, it’s best to speak with an annuity specialist. Watch this short video to see how I can help you do this (at no cost to you!)
Tip: See how much an annuity could pay you using our annuity calculator
Why variable annuities usually aren’t the “safest”
If your priority is safety, variable annuities typically don’t fit.
Why? Because your value is tied to subaccounts that move with the market. That means:
- Your account value can go down.
- Fees can be higher and harder to understand.
- “Safety” often depends on optional riders, not the core structure.
If what you want is principal protection and simple guarantees, keep reading.
Safest option #1: Fixed annuities (MYGAs) for pure safety and predictable growth
A fixed annuity—often called a MYGA (Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity)—is basically the annuity version of a CD.
Here’s why retirees love them:
- Fixed interest rate for a set term (often 2–10 years)
- Not tied to the stock market
- No market loss risk
- Straightforward and “boring” (in a good way)
What fixed annuities are best for:
- Parking money safely for a set time
- Earning a strong guaranteed rate (when rates are favorable)
- Potentially taking interest income (depending on the contract)
💡 Pro Tip: If you want access to interest without surrender charges, look for MYGAs designed with that flexibility. A slightly lower rate can be worth it if you want easier access.
👉 Want help comparing today’s top MYGA rates (by term and features)? Schedule a call with me.
Safest option #2: Fixed index annuities (FIAs) for safety + upside potential
A fixed index annuity is built for people who want:
- Market protection (no downside from market drops)
- Plus some upside linked to an index (like the S&P 500)
FIAs typically work like this:
- Your principal is protected from market losses (based on contract rules)
- Your growth is linked to an index, but you don’t get 100% of the upside
- The insurance company limits upside using participation rates or caps
Why they can be “safe”:
- If the market drops, your annuity generally doesn’t drop due to the index movement
- When the market rises, you can earn interest based on the index formula
👉 Want to see which FIAs are actually worth considering (and which to avoid)? Book a call here.
The biggest “safety mistake”: picking the wrong index (or the wrong advisor)
This is where people get burned.
Some annuities use well-known indexes like the S&P 500. Others use “branded” or complicated indexes that sound impressive but often disappoint in real results.
What to watch out for:
- Proprietary or “fancy” indexes marketed as superior
- Index variations that sound like the Nasdaq but aren’t truly the Nasdaq
- Advisors pushing products mainly because commissions are higher
A safer approach:
- Favor reputable carriers with a track record of keeping crediting terms competitive
- Favor simple, transparent index choices
- Make sure the annuity matches your goal (growth vs income)
💡 Pro Tip: With FIAs, the index choice and the crediting terms can matter more than the sales pitch. If you don’t understand how you earn interest, don’t sign.
Participation rates vs caps: which is safer for results?
Many FIAs credit interest using one of two methods:
1) Participation rates (you get a percentage of the index gain)
Example concept: “You get 55% of the index gain.”
This can be attractive because strong years can still credit meaningful returns, even with limits.
2) Caps (your gains are limited to a maximum)
Example concept: “You can earn up to X% this year, even if the index does more.”
Caps can work, but if caps are low, results can be underwhelming.
In John’s experience, solid participation rates on a straightforward index often outperform “low cap” designs over time—assuming the carrier keeps those terms competitive.
The safest way to create lifetime income: income riders (not “parking” money first)
This part is critical.
A MYGA can be great for safe growth. But if your main goal is lifetime income, “parking” money in a MYGA first often leads to lower lifetime payouts than using the right income-focused annuity strategy from the start.
Why? Because lifetime income is usually driven by an income base and a guaranteed payout factor, not just the account value.
Simple idea:
- MYGA = great for guaranteed accumulation or interest income
- Income rider strategy = often better for maximizing guaranteed lifetime income
💡 Pro Tip: Before you buy anything, decide your #1 goal:
- Safe growth
- Interest income
- Guaranteed lifetime income
The safest annuity is the one that’s built for your actual purpose.
👉 If you want lifetime income, I can show you the contracts designed specifically to maximize it—schedule a free consultation.
Conclusion
If your definition of “safe” is protecting principal and avoiding market losses, then the safest types of annuities are typically:
- Fixed annuities (MYGAs) for straightforward, guaranteed rates
- Fixed index annuities (FIAs) for principal protection with controlled upside
- And for retirees prioritizing paychecks: income rider strategies designed for lifetime income
The key is matching the product to the goal—and avoiding confusing indexes and commission-driven recommendations.
Need help with finding the best annuity for your retirement?
Click here to schedule a call with me.
On the call, I can help you:
- Determine what type of annuity is best for you
- Find the highest paying annuities for your unique situation
- Answer any other questions you may have