Indexed Annuity vs Fixed Annuity: Which is better?

When planning for retirement, you’re faced with a myriad of investment choices, and understanding the nuances of each option is crucial. 

Index annuities and fixed annuities stand out in the field of retirement planning – but how do they differ, and which one might be right for you?

This article focuses on demystifying the index annuity vs fixed annuity debate, presenting a clear, comprehensive guide to help you make an informed decision.


  • Fixed annuities offer a guaranteed interest rate and provide a secure, predictable income. They are ideal for conservative investors who prioritize stability over high returns.
  • Indexed annuities tie potential earnings to a market index with a minimum guaranteed rate, suitable for those willing to accept some market risk for the possibility of higher gains.
  • Choosing between fixed and indexed annuities depends on personal financial goals, risk tolerance, and retirement planning. Fixed annuities are favored for certainty, while indexed annuities are favored for growth potential.

Need help choosing the best type of annuity for your unique situation? Have questions about getting an annuity? If so, it’s best to speak with an annuity specialist. Watch this short video to see how I can help you do this (at no cost to you!)

Understanding Fixed and Indexed Annuities

Annuities significantly shape our retirement income. They are contracts with insurance companies, where we make premium payments in exchange for a fixed interest rate, variable return, or a guaranteed income stream.

Given each type’s unique benefits, your personal financial goals and risk tolerance predominantly determine the choice between fixed, indexed, and variable annuities.

Fixed annuities are the torchbearers of safety, building up retirement savings with the security of a steady, lifetime monthly income.

On the other hand, indexed annuities offer the potential to participate in the stock market’s upsides with protection against market downturns, which can provide higher returns compared to fixed annuities’ fixed interest rates.

The Foundation of Fixed Annuities

A fixed annuity is a contract that ensures that both the principal and the rate of return on your investment are guaranteed by the insurance company. It represents a commitment between you and the insurer.

The rates are locked-in for the life of the contract, providing a steady, predictable income stream. Companies like Royal Neighbors offer a 10-year fixed annuity option at an interest rate of 5.8% (February 2024) as a concrete product example.

Fixed annuities are attractive options for retirement planning because they are simple and predictable. They lack complex features and provide regular, predictable income, making them suitable for those who prefer certainty over surprise.

The Dynamics of Indexed Annuities

Fixed index annuities are also known as another reliable option for retirement. They credit interest based on changes in a specified market index, providing a blend of features from both fixed and variable annuities.

The interest in fixed index annuities is tied to stock market indices like the S&P 500, allowing for potential gains when the market performs well.

However, these potential gains do come with certain conditions. Interest earnings are contingent upon the performance of the linked index and can be subject to:

  • a cap on maximum earnings
  • participation rates that determine the percentage of index gains accounted for in returns
  • rate caps that limit the maximum return in a given year

But fear not, a minimum guarantee protects against market declines by ensuring that an indexed annuity does not lose principal and may credit a small guaranteed rate, typically between 1-3% per year.

Need help choosing the best type of annuity for your unique situation? Have questions about getting an annuity? If so, it’s best to speak with an annuity specialist. Watch this short video to see how I can help you do this (at no cost to you!)

Comparing Fixed and Indexed Annuities: A Side-by-Side Look

While conservative investors typically prefer the stability of fixed annuities without market risk, those open to partial market exposure for potentially higher returns may find indexed annuities a more appealing choice. 

We will further explore the subtleties of these two types of annuities.

Interest Rate Scenarios

One of the defining features of fixed annuities is the stable and guaranteed interest rate set by the insurance company when the annuity contract begins.

On the other hand, indexed annuities ensure a guaranteed minimum interest rate, typically between 1 to 3 percent, on a substantial portion of the premium, often at least 87.5 percent.

However, the game-changer is the fluctuating interest rate based on the performance of a specific market index they are tied to.

Withdrawal Terms

Every investment has its own set of rules, and annuities are no exception. Withdrawing funds from fixed and indexed annuities before the end of the surrender period may incur surrender charges, which typically decrease over time.

However, indexed annuities offer a little more flexibility. They may allow for a penalty-free withdrawal of up to 10%, providing some liquidity options for the annuity holder. 

Charges and Fees

When it comes to costs, indexed annuities may charge for certain features like riders, whereas fixed annuities commonly charge administrative fees of around 0.3% of the contract value.

However, certain fixed annuities may waive surrender charges for qualifying events such as disability, death, or the need for long-term care, allowing for a lump sum payment. 

Delving into Fixed Annuities

With guaranteed minimum interest rates for the life of the contract or specific periods, they provide stable and predictable returns similar to other low-risk financial products like CDs or bonds.

Moreover, immediate and deferred annuities, particularly deferred fixed annuities, bring the benefit of tax-deferral to the table, allowing earnings to grow tax-free until they are withdrawn, a particularly appealing aspect for retirement savings.

Pros of Fixed Annuities

The advantages of fixed annuities are numerous, including:

  • Offering a secure retirement income with a guaranteed fixed interest rate
  • Providing stability for predictable financial planning
  • Being a safer investment option for seniors

Fixed annuities offer several benefits, including:

  • Low minimum investment requirements, making them accessible to those not willing to commit a large sum of money up front
  • Lower costs due to minimal fees and no risk charges or front-end sales charges
  • A death benefit that ensures beneficiaries receive the remaining funds in the event of the annuity owner’s death.

Cons of Fixed Annuities

Despite the many benefits, fixed annuities also have their drawbacks. 

  • They offer a lower minimum guaranteed interest rate, limiting potential gains during market upswings. 
  • Owners of fixed annuities do not benefit from positive market performance due to the set interest rate.
  • One of the most significant downsides is that fixed annuities may not keep pace with inflation, posing a risk to purchasing power over time. For those looking for a balance between risk and return, this may be a crucial factor to consider.

Need help choosing the best fixed annuity for your unique situation? Watch this short video to see how I can help you do this (at no cost to you!)

Unlocking the Potential of Indexed Annuities

Entering the world of indexed annuities, we discover an environment brimming with possibilities and opportunities. They offer the potential for higher returns compared to traditional fixed annuities, particularly if the stock market performs well, with returns tied to indices such as the S&P 500.

While providing the opportunity for increased returns, indexed annuities also ensure a financial safety net through a minimum guaranteed interest rate to protect the investor’s capital.

They are a hybrid of fixed and variable annuities, granting protection against market downturns; they do not decrease in value even if the linked market index does.

Advantages of Indexed Annuities

Indexed annuities have advantages. 

  • They often provide higher long-term expected returns compared to guaranteed accounts like fixed annuities or CDs, helping to outpace inflation.
  • Investors also benefit from principal protection, which safeguards the initial investment against market downturns.
  • Minimum guaranteed returns in indexed annuities range from 1-3% per year, offering a baseline of reliability in income during retirement. This potential for greater returns allows for better rates than Certificates of Deposit (CDs).

These vehicles are well-suited for savvy investors and younger clients seeking higher returns without taking on excessive risk.

Disadvantages of Indexed Annuities

However, indexed annuities do come with certain limitations. 

  • The interest credited to an indexed annuity contract can be affected by various contractual limitations such as participation rates and spreads or asset fees that can reduce the overall rate.
  • During times of strong market performance, interest caps can severely restrict the returns credited to the annuity. Moreover, insurers may alter contractual features such as fees, participation rates, and caps, which can lead to lower returns for investors and affect the long-term profitability of the annuity.
  • The diverse methods used to calculate index changes and credit interest, along with contractual complexities, make it challenging for investors to fully understand and compare different indexed annuities.

Need help choosing the best indexed annuity for your unique situation? Watch this short video to see how I can help you do this (at no cost to you!)

Finding Your Annuity Match

The decision between a fixed and indexed annuity isn’t universal. It demands individual consultation to identify the ideal annuity match, considering the investors’ financial objectives, risk preference, and investment period.

Conservative investors not willing to risk their money in the market may find fixed annuities more suitable due to their guaranteed growth.

On the other hand, investors with longer investment horizons may lean towards indexed annuities, which offer a chance for higher growth while providing some protection against negative market performance.

Therefore, clarifying the annuity’s primary role—whether to generate income in the future, provide a death benefit, or ensure safe growth—is essential in determining whether to choose a fixed or indexed annuity.

Investing in Certainty or Embracing Potential?

Opting for certainty or potential is an individual decision influenced by personal financial objectives, risk capacity, and investment span. Fixed annuities can offer guaranteed ending balances which provide a predictable return on investment.

Companies like ClearSpring offer such guarantees, ensuring a specific amount of money is available at annuity’s maturity. These guarantees are attractive to investors seeking stability and assurance in their retirement income.

On the other hand, indexed annuities:

  • Do not offer guaranteed ending balances
  • Have the potential for higher returns linked to market performance
  • Offer an opportunity for investors to reap the benefits of a thriving market while still providing a safety net during downturns.

Making the Most of Your Retirement Savings

Annuities can transform into a vital part of a retirement plan, offering enduring income steadiness, supplementing additional retirement funds like Social Security, and acting as a financial shield against market fluctuations.

Fixed and indexed annuities both offer tax-deferred growth, enabling the invested money to accumulate interest without immediate tax liabilities; this allows for the growth of retirement funds at a potentially faster rate compared to taxable accounts.

A retirement portfolio may be structured to include annuities in strategic ways, such as substituting them for a portion of bond allocation, or balancing growth and preservation needs before retirement to minimize the impact of economic downturns.

Moreover, with the passage of the SECURE Act, annuities can be included in 401(k) options, presenting an additional avenue for accumulating retirement savings.


Understanding the nuances between fixed and indexed annuities is vital to sound retirement planning. While fixed annuities offer predictability and stability, indexed annuities provide an opportunity for potentially higher returns with some protection against market downturns.

The choice ultimately depends on individual financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment horizon. 

As with any financial decision, it’s crucial to do your homework, consult with an annuity advisor, and make an informed decision that aligns with your retirement goals and aspirations.

Booking a call with an annuity expert can provide you with personalized guidance on annuity strategies, and help you make informed decisions about your retirement income.

They can help you with:

  • Navigating complex investments
  • Making individualized recommendations
  • Providing support as needs change over time
  • Helping you reach your financial goals, including maximizing the use of annuities

Click here to schedule a call.

Frequently Asked Questions

Scroll to Top