If you’re thinking about buying an income annuity, there are a few things you need to know before you sign anything. In my experience, this is where a lot of people get blindsided. They’re shown one or two annuities, told it’s a great fit, and never really shown what else is available.
That’s a problem.
Because when you buy an income annuity, you’re often making a long-term decision with a large amount of money. If the product isn’t structured the right way, or if no one explains the tradeoffs clearly, you may end up locked into something that doesn’t actually do what you wanted it to do.
I talk to people all the time who say, “I thought I understood what I was buying.” But later, they realize they wanted lifetime income, better growth, more flexibility, or simply a better payout than what they were offered.
That’s exactly why I believe you should go into this process with your eyes wide open.
Need help choosing the best annuity for your unique situation? Have questions about getting an annuity? If so, it’s best to speak with an annuity specialist. Watch this short video to see how I can help you do this (at no cost to you!)
Tip: See how much an annuity could pay you using our annuity calculator
Most people are only shown one to three options
One of the biggest issues I see is that many buyers assume the annuity being presented to them is the best one available.
Sometimes it is a decent product. Sometimes it’s okay. Sometimes it’s not even close to the best option.
A lot of advisors and brokers only have access to a limited number of annuities. That means the product they’re recommending may simply be the one they can sell, not necessarily the one that gives you the highest income, the best terms, or the best fit for your goals.
If you are only looking at one illustration, you are not really shopping. You are being shown only a slice of the market.
That’s why I always tell people to compare multiple options before they make a decision.
👉 Want help comparing income annuities the right way? Schedule a call with me and I’ll walk you through the options from my perspective, not a sales pitch.
The highest payout may not be the one you’re being pitched
This is something most brokers do not say clearly enough.
Two annuities can look similar on the surface, but the payout can be dramatically different. One product might generate meaningfully more lifetime income than another, even when the same age, premium amount, and start date are used.
That matters.
If you’re putting a large sum of money into an annuity for retirement income, a lower-paying contract can cost you tens of thousands of dollars over time. In some cases, it can mean hundreds of thousands or more over a long retirement.
And the frustrating part is this: many buyers never even know the better option existed.
My view is simple. Before you buy anything, you should know what the top-paying options are, what the tradeoffs are, and whether you are prioritizing income, growth, liquidity, or guarantees.
Surrender charges and liquidity matter more than people realize
An income annuity is not the kind of product you should buy casually.
Many annuities come with surrender periods that can last five to ten years. During that time, if you need to pull out too much money, you may face surrender charges. That does not automatically make the annuity bad, but it does mean you need to understand what you are giving up before you commit.
Now, if your goal is lifetime income, you may never plan to surrender the contract anyway. That’s fair.
But you still need to know:
- How long the surrender period lasts
- How much you can withdraw each year without penalty
- What happens if you need the money early
- Whether you have enough liquid assets outside the annuity for emergencies
I always want people to keep enough money outside the annuity so they do not feel trapped. That way, the annuity can do its job, and your other assets can handle the unexpected.
💡 Pro Tip: Never put so much into an annuity that a surprise expense forces you to surrender it early.
👉 Want to know how much is reasonable to place into an income annuity versus keeping liquid? Schedule a call with me and I’ll help you think it.
Fees are real, but the real question is whether they’re worth it
Another thing that often gets oversimplified is fees.
Some annuities do not have direct annual fees, such as certain MYGAs, SPIAs, and DIAs. But when you add an income rider, there is usually a fee attached. And that fee needs to be clearly explained.
What many buyers miss is that the rider fee may be based on the benefit base, not the actual account value.
That’s a big distinction.
So when someone tells you the rider fee is around 1% or a little more, you need to ask exactly what it is charged against and what you are getting in exchange for it.
In many cases, the fee can absolutely be worth it if the annuity produces significantly more lifetime income. If paying the rider fee leads to much higher annual income over a long retirement, that may be a good tradeoff.
But you still need to compare both versions:
- The annuity with the rider
- The annuity without the rider
Only then can you judge whether the extra income justifies the cost.
Too many people hear “fee” and immediately reject the product, or hear “guaranteed growth” and immediately accept it, without doing the math. The right answer depends on your goals.
Upfront bonuses can be very misleading
This is one of the most common sales angles in the annuity world.
A broker might say, “You’ll get a bonus,” and that sounds great. Who doesn’t like free money?
But here’s the issue: a bonus does not automatically mean you are getting the best income annuity.
Sometimes the bonus goes to the income base, not the actual cash value you can walk away with. Other times, even when the premium bonus is real, the contract makes up for it somewhere else through lower long-term growth, weaker terms, or lower overall value.
Insurance companies do not give away money for nothing!
If a product advertises a very attractive upfront bonus, you need to ask what you are giving up in return. In many cases, the bonus is more of a marketing tool than a genuine advantage.
What matters most is not the bonus headline.
What matters is this:
- What is the actual lifetime income?
- What is the growth rate after the bonus?
- What are the fees?
- How strong is the contract overall?
That is the real analysis.
👉 Want help looking past the bonus hype and comparing what actually pays the most? Schedule a call with me and I’ll help you sort through it clearly.
Pressure and urgency are major red flags
This is one of the biggest warning signs I can give you.
If someone is pushing you hard to buy this week, today, or immediately, you need to slow down and think carefully.
Now, to be fair, there are times when rates can change. A broker should tell you that if it is truly relevant. But in most cases, the “act now” pitch is more about creating pressure than protecting your outcome.
Could rates change? Yes.
Could income payouts go lower? Yes.
Does that mean you should let someone rush you into a major retirement decision? No.
In my experience, if you feel like you’re being sold, you probably are.
You should never feel pressured to buy an annuity. You should feel informed. You should feel like the numbers make sense. You should feel like your questions are being answered honestly.
That is how this process should work.
When I talk with people, I focus on what they are actually trying to accomplish. Are they single or married? Do they want joint income? How much do they want to invest?
Are they comfortable with lower-rated carriers for a higher payout, or do they want only A-rated companies? Those are the conversations that matter.
Transparency is what you should expect before buying
At the end of the day, buying an income annuity should not feel confusing or rushed.
You should know:
- What the highest-paying options are
- What the fees are
- What the surrender charges are
- Whether a bonus is meaningful or just marketing
- Whether the rider is worth it
- Whether the recommendation fits your goals
That is the level of transparency you deserve.
I believe the best way to shop for an annuity is to compare real numbers, understand the tradeoffs, and make the decision from a position of clarity. That is why I encourage people to research first, ask direct questions, and avoid being boxed into a product they do not fully understand.
Need help with finding the best annuity for your retirement?
Click here to schedule a call with me.
On the call, I can help you:
- Determine what type of annuity is best for you
- Find the highest paying annuities for your unique situation
- Answer any other questions you may have